Sudhir Singh is a global HR leader in the San Francisco Bay Area. He is the Vice President of People at Sound Agriculture.
getty
In 1961, President Dwight D. Eisenhower established a valuable prioritization tool: the importance-urgency matrix. Stephen Covey further popularized this concept in The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People, referring to it as the habit of putting first things first. For over 60 years now, businesses and individuals have used this matrix to prioritize their actions.
However, it's not a flawless system. Defining what’s important is subjective. For example, a business might attach high importance to certain features in their product or service, but their customers might deem them less significant compared to other features. Similarly, an individual might feel saving money for the future is paramount, but it may actually be more important to focus on deteriorating health. On top of that, urgency is subject to change. Filing tax returns may not be urgent three months prior to the filing date, but it becomes super urgent on the eve of the tax filing deadline.
Rather than hanging on to Einsenhower's matrix, I decided to come up with my own: the meaning-comfort matrix. This takes into account the impact of events or activities, as well as the level of ease it takes to complete them.
The Axes Of The Meaning-Comfort Matrix
Like any coordinate plane, the meaning-comfort matrix is built from two perpendicular axes that create four quadrants. Let's look at the axes.
The Horizontal Axis: Meaning
The meaning axis is the horizontal line of the matrix, along which you determine an activity's meaning—its impact on you and those around you. As you move further left, an activity's meaning increases; as you move further right, it's less meaningful.
Meaningful activities have positive impacts, and the larger the impact, the more meaningful the activity. For example, launching an eco-friendly initiative in your business to reduce waste and support sustainability would be a meaningful activity. For an individual, pursuing higher education or professional certifications to enhance their expertise is meaningful.
Conversely, meaningless activities have limited or adverse impacts on you and your ecosystem. Scrolling through social media for hours without purpose is meaningless because it introduces little to no positive impact on your life. In business, a meaningless activity might be generating reports that no one can use effectively.
The Vertical Axis: Comfort
The comfort axis is the vertical line of the matrix, along which you determine an activity's comfort or familiarity. As you move down, an activity's comfort increases; as you move up, it becomes less comfortable.
Comfortable activities easily fall within your comfort zone. They're your tried and true, with known and favorable outcomes. Staying in the same role for years or always living in your hometown could be very comfortable. However, the more familiar you are with an activity, the fewer opportunities there are for any new experiences or learnings.
Uncomfortable activities reside in uncharted territory or appear difficult to accomplish. They require a willingness to explore and can offer immense learning opportunities. For example, giving a speech for the first time might be uncomfortable. For businesses, deciding to collaborate with competitors to address industry-wide challenges could seem difficult.
The Quadrants Of The Meaning-Comfort Matrix
With the background set, let's construct the meaning-comfort matrix and its quadrants.
1. The Meaningful-Uncomfortable Quadrant
As a professional or a business, the meaningful-uncomfortable quadrant is where you can maximize the returns on your efforts. Obviously, focusing on high-impact activities is a no-brainer; choosing uncomfortable ones is less easy. However, while activities in this quadrant aren't familiar, engaging in them enhances your knowledge and skills. For example, starting a new business venture to provide clean energy solutions is both meaningful and uncomfortable. It may require acquiring new skills and taking risks, but the positive impact it can have on the environment and society is substantial. For individuals, learning a new language to connect with different cultures and expand career opportunities could also fall into this quadrant.
2. The Meaningful-Comfortable Quadrant
This is the next best quadrant to operate in, as success is highly likely but there may be nothing new to learn. For instance, if you're an experienced writer, writing a book on a subject you're passionate about is meaningful, but it'd be within your comfort zone. Making charitable donations to support social causes aligned with a company's values is another example of a meaningful yet comfortable activity.
3. The Meaningless-Comfortable Quadrant
This quadrant usually consists of unproductive habits that are performed without much attention to their outcomes. Don’t be surprised to find a very long list of things in this quadrant; most of our time is spent here. An example of a meaningless-comfortable activity could be watching television shows that don't contribute to personal or professional growth. Micromanaging employees, instead of empowering them to make decisions and take ownership, may feel comfortable for people leaders, but its impact would likely be very negative. Identifying and eliminating activities in this quadrant is crucial for optimizing time and resources.
4. The Meaningless-Uncomfortable Quadrant
There may be times when we choose to engage in exciting or intriguing activities that have neither a positive impact nor align with our ecosystem. Chasing trends or fads without considering their real significance certainly falls into this quadrant. So does engaging in aggressive or unethical marketing tactics that can harm a company's reputation. These actions involve unnecessary effort and risk that's best avoided. Ideally, this quadrant would be empty for most businesses and individuals. If so, keep it that way.
Leveraging The Meaning-Comfort Matrix
When using the meaning-comfort matrix to determine the value of activities, here's a productive strategy to operate by. Focus on things that fall into the meaningful-uncomfortable quadrant while continuing to deliver on everything in the meaningful-comfortable quadrant. Then, make active efforts to empty your meaningless-comfortable quadrant and avoid anything that may fall in the meaningless-uncomfortable quadrant.
Using this decision matrix mindfully can lead to the best use of your time and resources, resulting in impactful outcomes. By stepping outside of your comfort zone, you open yourself up to new opportunities for growth and success and the ability to make a positive difference in your business and life.
Forbes Human Resources Council is an invitation-only organization for HR executives across all industries. Do I qualify?
